Forever Our Sunshine Boy: A Mother’s Journey Through Grief, Love, and Purpose

Forever Our Sunshine Boy: A Mother’s Journey Through Grief, Love, and Purpose

In this personal conversation, Will Carrington, SUDC dad to Maria and a trained peer support group facilitator with the SUDC Foundation, speaks with Claire Zurheide, SUDC mom to Teddy, about motherhood, grief, remembrance, and the experiences that shaped her journey toward supporting grieving children and families.

Claire was also one of eight storytellers who participated in the TMI Project at the SUDC Foundation’s 2026 Community Retreat, where she shared her family’s story with the SUDC community.

Will: Tell us about your family, Claire.  

Claire: My husband Paul and I got married in 2018 and moved from Los Angeles to New York City shortly after so I could pursue my dream job as a stage manager for American Ballet Theatre. We got pregnant with our first son, Logan, and he was born at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic in May of 2020. From my hospital room we could see the refrigeration trucks holding the bodies of all those who had died. But even amongst the pain and loss of the pandemic, we had such joy. At the hospital, the nurse arrived with my baby, “Here he is, Mom!” She handed him to me and, careful of my incision, I took him in my arms. “Hi Logan!” I’m beaming and Paul is beside himself. 

As soon as I met Logan, I knew I was meant to have another child.  Seventeenth months later I lay in another hospital bed, coming off the anesthesia of my second C-section. We head into the NICU to meet our second son…My Teddy! I kiss his tiny forehead and cheek. I hold his little hand, and his fingers wrap around mine. I breathe him in. 

“Hi Teddy. I’m your Mommy.” Nothing in my life has ever felt like this moment. Not the bliss that came when I drank, not the connection I felt in a room of other alcoholics at my favorite AA meeting. This is what being whole feels like. I feel like I am floating. 

This is why I’m here. To be their Mommy.

The day we brought Teddy home will always be the happiest day of my life. Logan was so sick, but as soon as he saw Teddy his eyes lit up. Logan was constantly hugging and kissing him and quickly learned how to say “Teeo-dore” in his sweet toddler voice. 

And Teddy adored Logan. 

He woke up every morning so happy to greet the day, a huge smile on his face. I always called Teddy: my sunshine boy, and he lit up every room he was ever in. Logan would climb into Teddy’s crib every morning and call out, “Mommy, we’re a-waaake!” 

One of my favorite memories happened about a month before Teddy died. Logan had (has) a lifelong love affair with vacuums and was always playing with them. This day, we had the big vacuum out and Logan was busy trying to unravel the cord to plug it in. Teddy had the little toy vacuum and was toddling around, glancing often at Logan to make sure he knew how to do it properly.

After Teddy was born, I was diagnosed with placenta accreta and underwent several procedures to try to fix my bleeding and repair the damage. When these were unsuccessful, I underwent a hysterectomy so I wouldn’t randomly open my scar and bleed out. 

We figured that since our family was complete and perfect with our two beautiful boys, we wouldn’t need my uterus anymore. How could we have known what would happen less than a year later? 

After Teddy’s death, I couldn’t fathom having another child and going through the worry, stress, and heartache of a potential additional loss, but now, sitting here speaking with you, I really wish I had that option. One thing I am saddest about is for Logan to grow up without a living brother. We had them so close together so they would have each other for their whole lives and (hopefully) be best friends… It breaks my heart every day that that can’t happen, especially when Logan asks for another brother.

 

Will: Could you tell us the circumstances of Teddy’s death?

Claire: The week Teddy died, we were supposed to be in California at Disneyland. ABT had their annual Nutcracker performances in Costa Mesa, so we had bought tickets for the boys to come join me afterwards. But my back went out, and I contracted COVID; and so, we made our usual trip to Bethany Beach, Delaware, where my father-in-law had a house, and where Paul’s mother and other family members lived a short car ride away. The plan was to be there until just after New Year’s and then return to New York City. 

We had a beautiful last day with Teddy, not knowing it would be his last. I heard Teddy and Logan wake up and, opening the door, there was my sweet Teddy, beaming at me. Always so happy to greet the day! And Logan! “Good morning, my loves!” I said, letting Paul go back to sleep.

Our family came over to visit, and we all had a pizza lunch. Teddy LOVED food, but this day he only ate a few bites. We figured he had picked up the bug Logan had at Christmas and got him some medicine for his slight fever.

The next morning was Paul’s turn to get up with the boys. He shouted, “Claire! Something’s wrong!” and I heard panic in his voice. I flew out of bed. I already knew that our precious Teddy was gone. He had died hours earlier and it was clear there was no bringing him back.

Will: What happened the rest of that day?

Claire: I’m so grateful that we were in Delaware. The response team supported us, and I really think our Family Victim Advocate saved my life. She suggested we call our family, and as soon as we did, they all came. Every one of them (except my elderly parents who live in Oregon). My brother drove up from Georgia, where he was visiting his in-laws for the holidays. Paul’s family all came in from wherever they were – NYC, Florida, Delaware. We spent the next week huddled on the floor of the living room, unable to return to the bedroom where we had laid Teddy’s body for the paramedics.

None of us knew what to do after Teddy died, and so Paul and I did the one thing that I know works – attend an AA meeting. I sat there, shaking in my seat, praying I would find something, anything, to help with this feeling, but I only felt anger, numbness, and dissociation. A man bogarted the meeting to talk about how buckets of live ammunition had gone off when his friend’s house had caught fire due to complete idiocy. Nobody was hurt, and the entire time, there was a voice screaming inside my head, “MY SON IS DEAD!” I left the meeting and went back out into the dark, cold night.

We went to another meeting a few days later and again found no relief there. No one’s problems were like mine. I used to be able to connect, but I felt dead inside and could not find comfort. I just wanted Teddy back. I didn’t want this reality to be my life.

Will: How long until you were able to return to your home?

Claire: We headed back to NYC when we got Teddy’s remains back, about two weeks after his death. My father-in-law had previously returned the bunk bed we had bought the boys as a Christmas present. Our apartment was small, and they were just getting bigger, so we had planned a fun, new renovation for the boys’ room. Friends and neighbors had sent care packages, food, and so many sympathy cards. We were surrounded by love, but I think I almost died from a broken heart. I ended up going to the ER not being able to breathe, but they couldn’t find anything wrong with me.

I was flooded with so many memories and the grief of what would never happen. The bathroom had the toys we used to play with in the tub. The living room was full of the presents we had just gotten Teddy for Christmas – toys he would never get to use. Taking my beautiful Logan to the playground often ended with me in a panic attack, unable to stop the stream of tears and unbearable pain of seeing other little siblings playing together. I had to call Paul in a panic multiple times, unable to stay.

Our apartment was so quiet, and Logan had the most difficult time going to sleep. We would spend hours trying to calm him to finally rest, and then I would be up for hours, watching true crime documentaries and horror movies, unable to bear the silence. I quit my job because I couldn’t stand the thought of being away from Logan, and for my company, life had moved on. Yes, my son was dead, but I was still expected to show up and set props for rehearsals? None of it made sense to me anymore.

Will: Did you change jobs or careers after Teddy died?

Claire: One day, months after quitting the job I used to love, Paul tells me, “You know, Brooklyn College has a degree in Thanatology.” “What? Like Thanos from the Avengers?” I looked it up immediately – the study of death, dying, and grief – and something finally clicked.

I have always loved learning. I am a born brown-noser, the daughter of two literature PhD professors. I like to sit in the front of the class, prepared and ready to go! I know my classmates usually hated me, but who cares? I’ve learned from AA there is no way out but through. So, I did it. I signed up for the thanatology classes to be that A+ student I’ve always been. I wanted to be able to help others like me, and to be a safe person people could go to in their worst moments. Most of all, I wanted to know how to help Logan so he could have a chance of a “normal” life. He was only two and a half! In my classes, I studied palliative care, child development as it relates to their understanding of death, trauma, PTSD, and so much more. Now I am working on my (5,000+!) hours I need for my Certificate of Thanatology.

Will: Please tell us about your subsequent move from New York to South Carolina.

Claire: Living in NYC was always difficult, but after Teddy died it felt impossible. We knew we couldn’t afford to live there without my job, and being surrounded by all the places and things we had hoped to do with our two boys only brought sorrow, guilt, and regret. Yes, there were so many happy memories, but Paul and I used to spend our nights before bed looking at photos of the boys and dreaming of the future … So, we started looking around and throwing darts at a map. 

We had friends who had moved to Charleston during the pandemic, and they loved it there. They made it sound so peaceful and easy, and we desperately needed a change. So, we started poking around for jobs, and then I found it – Program Coordinator at a small non-profit called Bridges of Hope. They provide a grief support community for children, teens, and their families. I sent in my application, and we booked a flight to go visit. I interviewed with them and felt immediately at home. It was a job where I could use my years of stage management experience to help grieving people!!  Paul got accepted as a teacher in a program where he could teach while working towards his certificate, AND it was beautiful! Close to the ocean and beaches, and so many new parks to explore with Logan. We found an apartment so easily – everything just came together and we didn’t have to struggle. So, we packed our bags and moved shortly after Logan’s forth birthday, one and a half years after Teddy’s death. I remember the first-time walking into Harris Teeter (a grocery store chain) and bursting into tears with gratitude because it was giant, bright, and had more selection than I had seen in all my years living in NYC.

My new job is full of challenges, and the most difficult is hearing the stories of so many families who have had traumatic losses and now the children are struggling and in need of support. The best part is being able to provide activities and space for these kiddos to grieve, to remember, and to connect with each other. It is a small organization, so I am busy all the time, but it also allows me to be of service and to know that I am making a difference. My boss and coworkers are so supportive, and I never feel awkward when I need to take some time for my own grief or share the dark thoughts going on in my head.

We were able to buy a house here about a year and a half ago- something I never thought we would be able to do! On Teddy’s forth birthday, we cleared a spot in our backyard and planted Teddy’s apple trees. He loved apples and would say “apple!” in his sweet little voice every time he would see one. I love going out and taking care of the garden, spending time on the bench we put there, and talking to him. I often look out the window and see cardinals flitting around and perching on the new branches. Logan goes out to sit on the bench and think about his brother. He will put heart-shaped leaves and different rocks on the bench for him. Paul and I have big plans about how we want to design the garden, and I love going to Lowe’s and finding flowers and plants that remind me of Teddy.

Will: How has Teddy’s death affected your parenting of Logan? 

Claire: Logan was the reason I got up in the morning after Teddy died, and some days that’s still true! After Teddy’s death, I was absolutely terrified of what would happen to Logan and his development. I had never known anyone who’d had to deal with a death like this. That’s really why I went back to school, and I’m so glad I did. For my own trauma, it took a long time to get over the worst of the PTSD symptoms. My therapist’s advice still echoes in my head when I am having a hard time or when I am triggered. I always think Paul has died if he doesn’t call me on his way home from work. I won’t let Logan ride the bus to school in fear that something will happen. The weekend of my overnight camp in early October, Paul and Logan drove up to Delaware for the funeral of a dear family member. He was there on Teddy’s last day, took us to that second AA meeting after Teddy died, and his kindness and presence in our life has been a blessing since I met Paul. I desperately wanted to attend the funeral, but there was no way I could miss camp, so the boys went up. It was such a difficult weekend, and any time I texted and didn’t get an immediate response, my mind went to the worst place… But they arrived there okay and got home just a few minutes after I did, so I didn’t have the chance to ruminate on their imminent demise in a horrific accident on the 95…

In terms of my parenting of Logan, I was always truthful, but now I am absolutely honest with him. I will always answer any questions he has, and I will never sugar-coat anything. I learned very early to use the word ‘death’ and how to describe it to small children – and to have faith that they can handle it. Children are so curious, and we do them a serious disservice when we cover up the truth, even when we feel like we are protecting them. Death is a part of life, and the earlier they are exposed to it, the better their relationship with it is and it doesn’t have to be so terrifying.

Will: How is your family doing?

Claire: Logan didn’t talk about Teddy for at least a year after he died. He never said his name, never asked where he was, never said anything about him. That broke my heart more than anything. But now he talks about him all the time. 

My job also gives Logan a place to go to connect with other grieving kids. In his everyday life, not many children can understand what he has been through, but the kids in our programs do. Next year, he will be able to go to our overnight camp, and I am so excited for him! My work also allows me to see how well he is doing and feel so grateful that I understand where he is developmentally and know that he will always have a relationship with Teddy, even though it’s not the one we had ever thought he would have.

Paul teaches 7th grade social studies, and it is very challenging. He is able to recognize and support children who are showing negative adaptive skills and know there is something deeper going on instead of just bad behavior. He is also very protective of the grieving children and is open about Teddy’s death with his students.

We got our dog, Gambit, a few months after we moved down here. Shortly after, my 17-year-old cat died, and we ended up getting a kitten after we moved into our new house. Then a few months later as a birthday present to myself, we drove 20 hours to and from Tennessee to get our newest addition, a basset hound named Roger. We wanted Logan to have siblings of a sort, and Paul and I have always been obsessed with dogs. Now they play around and tear up the house, causing havoc and making me yell! It helps to fill the silence. We also still think about potentially adopting a baby, but it’s too much for my head to wrap around for the moment. If I could get pregnant, I absolutely would… Would we have so many pets if Teddy were alive? Absolutely not! But it brings me comfort and joy to see them with each other. And I have a special bond with Roger. He brings a Teddy energy to our lives that I have desperately been missing.

Now we see Teddy in the rainbows that the little crystals hanging on our window make in the afternoon sunlight. He lives on in the heart-shaped leaves we spot regularly on the ground and in the cardinals that flit around our neighborhood and Teddy’s garden. 

At night, I snuggle Logan tight as he begins to drift off to sleep. 

“I miss Teddy,” I tell him quietly. “I wish he were here.”

“He is, Mom! He’s right here!”



Skip to content